Quibble No.2: Facebook Follies

((pretend there's a photo here, a friend posing with me, a friend we'll call Pepper))

The caption should say:

Pepper and I

or

Me and Pepper / Pepper and me

?

It's me, not I.

Really.

But everyone says--

No. It's me, not I.

At least when it comes to photos or when I'm breaking up with you.